Why I don’t support a NZ republic

Well, nothing at all is happening in NZ politics, so, in a desperate attempt to blog I’m going to state my view on NZ republicanism.

And, as you may have guessed from the title of this post, I support the retention of the monarchy.


  • It risks giving a political party too much power. If a president is aligned to a political party, they will have every reason to block bills that their party does not support. This could result in political deadlock.
  • It makes sure we still have good ties with the UK. The fact that we are still technically under the control of the crown means that the UK and us will still have good relations. As the UK is still absolutely a world power, this is very advantageous.
  • It reminds us of our history. Both the good and the bad when New Zealand was a colony was done under the name of the crown. While the Queen is our head of state will be forced to both confront the bad and embrace the good of NZ history. If there was a president, there would be an easy excuse.
  • The Treaty was signed between the Maori tribes and the crown. The treaty is what makes sure we treat both Pakeha and Maori equally. If we get rid of the monarchy, what happens to that agreement?
  • The Queen doesn’t have a political opinion. Ok, well she probably does, but she probably doesn’t have a political opinion relevant to New Zealand. A president will. Especially if they are a party based, their political views may influence their actions.
  • Finally, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!

So yeah. That’s why I can say that I’m a monarchist.


  1. Raoul Ketko

    Looks like a good topic for a debate at your school. Think about it.

  2. Chris Morris

    I agree with you, Dan. Being a constitutional monarchy is a lot better than the alternatives.
    Another important thing that makes it good is judges, policy and the military swear allegiance to the Queen, not the government. That removes one level of political interference..

    1. mike

      good point Chris

  3. Caleb

    I agree Dan – good job.

  4. Mike Mckee

    I’m torn but see the sense in both arguments.

    1. Tomsk

      It is interesting that Farrar at kiwiblog goes down the leftist favourite track of identity politics. Calling the royal family German Greek.
      Of course he would never apply that standard to NZers whose forebears were born in the 19th century like Queen Victoria. Farrar would say someone who lived most of their lives in NZ was a NZer. What a triple standard!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *